Lovely Little Shelf

Review: The Sweet Far Thing

The Book: The Sweet Far Thing, by Libba Bray

The Story: This is the last book of a trilogy.  If you haven’t read the first two, but plan to, you may want to skip this part.

This starts pretty soon after the last book left off.  Gemma and Co. are returning to Spence Academy after all that crazy stuff went down at the end of Rebel Angels.  They get back together and try to get back into the Realms.  They can’t.  They’re freaking out.

When they do finally find their way back in, Pippa seems creepy and she has a band of girls with her that Gemma and Co. befriend.  Gemma has all of the magic from the Realms and the girls use it for various things, none of them particularly useful.  Everyone in the Realms wants a piece of this cake, but Gemma isn’t ready to let go yet.

Gemma is having crazy visions of a lady in a purple dress.  The girls run around tricking people and doing crazy things.  The Realms are kind of going crazy and Gemma and Co. try to figure out how to fix it without destroying everything that they’ve done so far.

What I thought: I was seriously disappointed in this book. I really liked the first two but found this one almost unreadable.  It drug every thing out so far that I just lost interest.  ”We went into the realms. Then we came back. Then we went back in. Then we came back,” over and over and over.

By the second half of the book, when the action picked up, I didn’t even hardly care anymore. I just wanted it to be over.

To be fair to Libba Bray, I do enjoy her writing style and I liked the characters and how they were changing and growing. It tied up all the loose ends and had some good surprises. But these didn’t make up for all of the flaws.  This was my least favorite book of hers that I have read.

Conclusion: While I didn’t love this book, I did enjoy the series as a whole, so I still recommend it.

2 Comments

  1. Posted November 30, 2009 at 10:01 pm | Permalink

    I felt the same way about the beginning! And then we went into the realms. And then Pippa was weird. And then we went back to the realms. And then Pippa was weird. On and on for 400 pages. It was only my love of all things Kartik that kept me going through the beginning. It seems like so much of that could have been cut.

    Then, I don’t know about you, but there was a serious WTF moment for me at the end. :-\

  2. Posted December 1, 2009 at 6:59 am | Permalink

    Yeah, a SERIOUS WTF moment that I had to read a few times to make sure that what I thought happened just happened… And I was still like “really?!”…